This past week in Megillot, we learned about the final speech of the חכם. As always, he starts his speech by responding to each of the other characters of Kohelet. He first responded to the נהנה. He tells his that he can scream like a fool and stomp his feet, but in the end everyone is going to listen to my quiet words of wisdom. He goes on to tell him that though he is loud, and that may get people to follow him, he is still an idiot because he doesn't have the wisdom. We can learn from this that we cannot be led astray by a loud, and "idiotic" leader.
Next comes the response to the עמל. He tells the עמל that no matter how hard he works to reach perfection, he is not going to because he doesn't have the wisdom. Lastly, we have the response to the יראי אלוקים. The חכם questions him. He asks, how do you know that there will be justice in the next world and it is served when you die. You do not have the ability to look further than life, because only I can do that with my wisdom.
After the חכם responds to everyone else, he gives his final opinions. He tells us that a leader should be noble, but money is also the answer for everything. We see that at the end of the חכם's speech he comes full circle back around, like all the other characters, and says that everything is hevel. He became all of the characters combine and said that once one finds MY wisdom, MY intelligence, and MY insight the world will be perfect.
The חכם did have a realization and in the realization I would like to focus on how much he used the words "I" and "my." He told all of the characters that the only way they can achieve perfection is by finding and applying wisdom to their lives. Nothing else will work. It was either the חכם's way or the highway.
Of all of the characters we have met so far, the Chacham's conclusion bothers me the most. From the offset, it seems like he had the potential to understand the world in the best way. Yes, he had some problems with the practical application of G-d's justice system in this world. This is understandable as man is somewhat incapable of understanding the world on the same level that G-d can. As a somewhat intellectual thinker myself, I find it quite odd that part of the conclusion that the Chacham would draw would be that money is the answer to everything. Why? It literally makes no sense. This disjointed conclusion suggests that there might be something unwritten going on here, something that was left out of the book intentionally. This is a real disappointment to me because I honestly thought that the Chacham would be able to come up with something better than "Hakol Hevel."
ReplyDeleteI agree with you. It happens in todays world too. People get so caught up in wanting their way, they take down everything and everyone that is an obstacle to them until it's their way. It's what the chacham is doing taking out the obstacles so he makes sure that everything goes his way.
ReplyDelete