This week we read through Perek 3. In this Perek, the speaker is a man from Bnei Yisroel. There is not that much information about who he is, but he goes through a lot of emotions through out the Perek.
He starts of by saying "I am the man who has seen the affliction by the rod of His wrath." and goes explaining what G-d did to him and how he is suffering. He then goes on saying that he still has hope. He says that G-d does not destroy for no reason, only because someone is worthy of destruction. He is recognizing that G-d destroyed him, because he sinned,and eventually g-d will forgive him and feel compassion towards him. He then even says that he sinned, and he shouldn't even be complaining - "Why should a living man complain? A man for his sins."
Recognizing you have sinned and recognizing that your sin is the reason why G-d destroyed you is already a giant step, he still then goes on. He then talks to Hashem. The man tells G-d that he recognizes he sinned and rebelled, and is basically asking for forgiveness. After coming to a conclusion that G-d will forgive him, he then point out that the other nations mocked Yerushaliam when she was in pain, and says that they should be punished.
When reading this Perek, on question came to mind. How come the man who actually was the one who sinned, was able to go through so many steps of repentance in one Perek, when Yerushaliam could not in two?
Interesting question...I think it might have to do with the fact that Yerushalayim is technically representing Bnei Yisrael as a whole, and they might not all be ready to repent yet, even if they recognize that it was their fault. The speaker in Perek Gimmel might just be ready to turn to G-d. Sometimes people need to just get all the anger and sadness out before they can move on to repentance. They were kind of just thrown out of their home, and whether or not it is right, they were probably preoccupied with the fact that they just lost everything and they have no where to go.
ReplyDeleteThis is a really good question and I didn't really think of it like that. I think that it comes down to 1) the fact that they experienced different types of pain or 2) the fact that the mysterious man copes with pain better/ or is more mature. I think that Shani was kind of saying the same thing as me. Everyone deals with situations differently and I just think that Yerushalayim probably felt more pain so it took her so long to get over it.
ReplyDelete